Over that past year I have tried out a good selection of paddle pogies in the cold water and weather of the Pacific Northwest. Most of my testing has been creeking on the local OR and WA creeks, but some high water playboating, surf kayaking, and flat-water workouts were also involved. I also enlisted a number of my paddling mates to provide me with their feedback on these pogie models. Each pogie has its pros and cons and everyone will have their personal preferences, but hopefully this info will help narrow the search for YOUR perfect pogies.
(Warmth rating on a 1-5 scale, 5 being the warmest.)
(Weight is physical weight of 1 pair of pogies as weighed on a digital postal scale.)
MSRP: $34.99, Closeout Price: $19.99 BUY NOW (NextAdventure.net)
Warmth Rating: 3
Weight: 6.6 oz
Materials: 3mm fleece lined neoprene
-Easy to get hands in and out.
-Short gauntlet allows lots of water into pogie.
-Not very warm (might be warmer with smaller hands).
-Small interior volume is quite tight around normal sized hands
Great creeking pogies for paddler’s with smaller hands.
MSRP: $43.50 BUY NOW
Warmth Rating: 5
Weight: 10.6 oz
Materials: 3mm Skin-Hypalon
-Easy to get in and out of quickly.
-Great wind protection.
-Absorbs much less water than typical neoprene, keeping the pogie lighter and warmer.
-Found that with a gripped paddle the heat of these pogies can cause blisters.
-Not good as a snot rag, due to smooth outer material.
-Heaviest pogie in this review.
High quality super warm pogie for all paddle sports uses.
MSRP: $29.95 BUY NOW (NextAdventure.net)
Warmth Rating: 2
Materials: 2mm neoprene, skin-out, with waterproof nylon cuff
-Great wind protection.
-Webbing snap feature on cuff is great for compact storage and drying.
-Not very warm.
-Not easy to get in and out of quickly, unless cuff is rolled down.
Best suited for flat-water applications where wind protection is of primary concern.
MSRP: $24.99 NA: $19.99 (Available at Next Adventure’s Paddle Sports Center, Portland, OR)
Warmth Rating: 4
Weight: 5.8 oz
Materials: 3mm neoprene
-Simple functional design.
-Seams and neoprene seem to wear quickly, although no tears or failures where experienced after much harsh use.
-Gauntlet is a bit floppy and sometimes hard to get into quickly.
The value pick, does most things well at a great price.
I have cold hands and paddle in cold water year round. I also enjoy small creeks that require me to grab rocks and tree limbs while catching micro eddies and stopping to scout rapids. Being the warmest pogies that I tested and being relatively easy to get in and out of quickly, the Snap Dragon Hyper Hands have become my personal favorites. I do have to say that if money is an issue, which it usually is, than the Neosport 3mm Pogie is really a great value.
-At the time of this review I was not sponsored or affiliated with any of the above companies, but was supplied with samples of each of these products for testing purposes.-